Feel like you’re the only person who likes fruit cake? These 5 can be delivered to your door in days

Top 5 fruit cakes you can order online

If you think finding the best holiday gift is hard, try finding the best dessert for a mixed crowd at holiday parties. While it’s smart to play it safe with pies or cookies, that means you might miss out on your personal favorite: fruit cake. Fortunately, you can order delicious varieties online — and these five will arrive at your door in time for your holiday festivities.

What you need to know about fruit cake 

What is fruit cake?

Fruit cake is a dense, moist dessert made with a mix of nuts, dried fruit and spices. The finished cake is “soaked” in brandy, rum or whiskey and wrapped in plastic wrap and foil for a few months. As expected, it’s not exactly a cake made the night or week before serving. In fact, most bakers recommend starting the fruit cake baking process at least six weeks in advance or earlier if possible. 

Fruit cake is often baked in tube or bundt cake pans, though some prefer regular cake or loaf pans. Modern takes on the baking process include using air fryers or cast iron skillets. Mini fruit cake varieties, which have risen in popularity recently, are often baked in muffin or bundt pans. 

Is fruit cake popular?

Fruit cake is a holiday dessert staple, but according to some people, it’s not the most popular option for parties and gatherings. Among other reasons, it’s an expensive cake to buy or make compared to other options. Some people simply aren’t fans of heavy, fruit-laden cakes, especially after eating large roast meals at holiday gatherings. Fruit cake may not be ideal for children, as some may prefer classic desserts like ice cream cake or apple pie. 

With that said, some people are diehard fruit cake lovers. Not only do they appreciate the intense flavor and aroma of the fruit cake, they know it’s made as a labor of love on behalf of the baker given the time investment it requires. 

Why you should buy fruit cake online

Because it’s fairly late in the season, many fruit cake lovers have decided to order the cakes, and it’s not just a matter of convenience.

For one, bakeries often have a limited number of fruit cakes to sell, and at this point, many of them have been purchased. As a result, buying the cake online might be the only option to get it in time for the holidays. 

While fruit cakes share many of the same ingredients, you’ll find several unique varieties online. There are now gluten-free fruit cakes and those packaged in single-serving portions. Certain fruit cakes may be soaked with your preferred liquor, as well.

How much are fruit cakes online?

Fruit cakes start at around $22, and some varieties run as high as $85. If you’re not eligible for free shipping or need the fruit cake sooner, be prepared to pay a premium to guarantee delivery on time. 

Indulge in these 5 fruit cakes you can buy online 

Jane Parker Fruitcake

Baked with a 1930s recipe, two-thirds of this 3-pound fruit cake contains fruit and nuts. It’s packaged in an attractive, gift-ready tin. 

Sold by Amazon

Trappist Abbey Monastery Fruit Cake

If you’re looking for a smaller fruit cake, this one measures 3 by 3 inches and weighs one pound. It’s made with 120-proof brandy and comes in a decorative tin. 

Sold by Amazon

Collin Street Bakery DeLuxe Fruitcake 

This popular fruitcake, featured on television shows, is made with juicy ripe red cherries from Washington and Oregon and contains 27% pecans. 

Sold by Amazon

Carli’s Cakes Original Fruit Cake

This affordable fruitcake trio is a top choice if you’re on a budget. Each loaf is chock-full with some of the finest nuts and fruit in the world. 

Sold by Amazon

Date Lady Gluten-Free Fruitcake

The award-winning fruitcake is gluten-free, Kosher and Paleo. The all-natural recipe is also free of added sugar, artificial sweeteners and corn syrup. 

Sold by Amazon

Sign up here to receive the BestReviews weekly newsletter for useful advice on new products and noteworthy deals.

Sian Babish writes for BestReviews. BestReviews has helped millions of consumers simplify their purchasing decisions, saving them time and money.

BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. BestReviews and its newspaper partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links.