Speaker Johnson’s unflinching bravery can unite a House divided

In this era of deep polarization and partisan strife, House Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.), a man of modest beginnings who once aspired to be a firefighter, has improbably emerged as an unlikely hero. A relative unknown before becoming Speaker, this political underdog from Louisiana has demonstrated that courage and a spirit of unity still have a place in American politics. 

Johnson’s recent bold actions to advance crucial foreign aid suggest a legacy-defining trajectory, reminiscent of Harry Truman’s rise from obscurity. At a pivotal moment for America on the global stage, Johnson is potentially transforming into a pivotal figure whose significance materialized almost unexpectedly.

Johnson’s decision to push for the passage of aid assistance for Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan was a maneuver requiring immense political courage, legislative skill and a profound understanding of America’s vital role in preserving global democracy and freedom. This decision came at significant personal risk, directly challenging the fractious isolationist factions within his own party seduced by the simplistic “America First” rhetoric exploiting fears of domestic decline. 

In advancing these measures, Johnson resisted the polarizing forces embodied by obstructionists like the Freedom Caucus and Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.).

Once a member of the conservative Freedom Caucus, many expected Johnson to toe their line. However, their agenda has deteriorated into political theatrics masquerading as principled conservatism, embarrassing our nation and shamefully delaying House approval of crucial aid. 

But, contrary to the prevailing media narrative that portrays him as another polarizing voice, Johnson has intentionally charted his own course. Guided by deep faith, intelligence and an innate decency reminiscent of Reagan’s affability — traits that should not be mistaken for weakness — Johnson’s decisive action in advancing foreign aid has redefined him as a model of rare leadership, evoking figures who have historically prioritized national interests over partisan loyalty at pivotal moments.

These events echo the storied transformation of Sen. Arthur Vandenberg (R-Mich.) from a proponent of isolationism to a supporter of internationalism after World War II. Like Vandenberg, Johnson’s courageous decision underscores the principle that “partisan politics [should stop] at the water’s edge,” and Americans should unite around foreign policy, not be divided by it. 

It reflects an understanding that America plays a pivotal role in the world as a force for democracy and freedom, a role that transcends partisan approaches. This situation demands the kind of historic statesmanship and leadership exemplified by American greats such as Vandenberg, Truman and Reagan.

While Johnson’s actions have sparked debate within the GOP, with some viewing his bipartisanship as a betrayal, others see it as a bold reaffirmation of the Reagan Doctrine of “peace through strength.” The greatest irony is that in a narrowly divided House Republican Conference, Johnson’s act of political bravery may be his last as the narcissists of the Freedom Caucus have promised his ouster. This action would be a complete disaster for House Republicans’ chances to retain their majority in the November election.

Johnson took this bold action fully aware of potential consequences, including a motion to vacate the Speaker’s chair, for upholding his duties. Now, not for his own sake but for America’s, he must once again exercise that same courageous leadership. 

In this time of global upheaval, it is imperative that the House remains a functioning, responsive branch of government. Echoing President Lincoln, “a house divided against itself cannot stand,” and no Speaker can effectively lead under the tyranny of an obstructionist few or one. 

America needs Johnson’s continued principled guidance, and the House rules must be restored to preserve order and democratic governance.

Earle Mack is a former United States ambassador to Finland. He is a partner with the Mack Company, a real estate development and investment firm, and a trustee of the Appeal of Conscience Foundation.